Hiring a new employee should feel exciting, not like rolling the dice and hoping for the best. But in reality, resumes can be polished, references can be rehearsed, and interviews can be a little… creative. That’s why businesses across many industries rely on pre-employment background checks and professional employee background investigation services to reduce risk and hire with confidence.

Private investigators bring experience, discretion, and a process that goes beyond the typical “quick check” most companies run. They verify facts, uncover inconsistencies, and help businesses avoid costly surprises. Because the truth is simple: one bad hire can create headaches that last months, but a solid investigation can prevent them in the first place.

In this guide, we’ll break down how private investigators verify employee backgrounds, what they look for, and how these findings support safer workplaces and better hiring decisions.

Pre-employment background checks are not just a formality. They are one of the smartest steps a business can take before handing someone access to customers, cash, company vehicles, sensitive data, or even just the office fridge. Hiring is not only about filling a role. It’s about protecting your team, your reputation, and your bottom line.

A strong screening process helps businesses avoid situations like:

• Hiring someone who exaggerated experience or credentials
• Bringing in an employee with a history of workplace violence or theft
• Adding staff who have patterns of misconduct in past roles
• Dealing with internal problems that could have been prevented upfront
  
  

And while many HR departments run basic checks, private investigators go deeper. A professional employee background investigation focuses on verification, context, and risk. In other words, they don’t just look at what’s listed, they confirm whether it’s real.

Common Business Benefits of Verified Hiring

Businesses that take screening seriously often experience:

• Lower turnover, because hires match the job requirements more accurately
• Fewer HR incidents, including harassment complaints and policy violations
• Reduced fraud risk, especially in positions involving finances or inventory
• Improved workplace trust, because employees feel safer around each other
  
  

Think of it like this: you wouldn’t buy a used car without popping the hood. A background check is your way of making sure you’re not hiring the corporate version of a vehicle held together by duct tape and good vibes.

How Private Investigators Perform an Employee Background Investigation

A professional employee background investigation is built on a detailed process. Private investigators verify identity, confirm work and education history, check for red flags, and document everything clearly. The goal is not to judge someone harshly for their past, but to give the business accurate information so leadership can make an informed decision.

Here are some of the key steps private investigators typically follow during the investigation:

1. Identity Verification

This is the foundation. Investigators confirm the person is who they claim to be and that key identifiers align. A surprising number of problems start right here, especially when names, prior addresses, or basic personal details don’t match.

2. Employment History Verification

Investigators confirm:

• Job titles
• Employment dates
• Supervisor or HR verification
• Responsibilities that match the resume
  
  

This is where embellishment often shows up. Some candidates “manage teams” on paper but in reality they were not exactly calling the shots.

3. Education and Credential Checks

Degrees, certifications, and licensing claims get verified. This is especially important for roles that require specialized skills or compliance standards.

4. Criminal History Checks

Depending on what is legally available and relevant, investigators review criminal records and related public documentation. Businesses are often less concerned with minor issues and more focused on patterns or incidents that could impact workplace safety or trust.

5. Professional Reference Interviews

Private investigators may conduct deeper reference checks than a standard call. They know how to ask questions that reveal real information, not just rehearsed praise.

6. Reporting and Recommendations

The findings are organized into a clear report. The goal is clarity, not confusion. A good investigator highlights verified facts, notes inconsistencies, and helps a business understand potential risks.

That structured approach is why businesses turn to professional investigators instead of relying on a quick online search and a gut feeling.

What Private Investigators Look for During Pre-Employment Background Checks

Pre-employment background checks are not about nitpicking tiny details. They’re about spotting risks that could become real problems after a hire is made. Private investigators focus on patterns, inconsistencies, and behavior that suggests the person may not be a good fit for the position or workplace.

Key Red Flags Investigators Watch For

Private investigators often look for things like:

• Resume inconsistencies: Employment dates that shift, vague job descriptions, or missing employers.
• Frequent unexplained job changes: Everyone has career transitions, but patterns matter.
• Unverifiable education or licensing: If a school, credential, or certification does not check out, that’s a major concern.
• History of workplace misconduct: Theft, harassment, or violence issues can put teams at risk.
• Identity issues: Misleading information about name history or previous addresses can be suspicious.
  
  

Helpful Details That Add Context

In addition to red flags, investigators also document positive verification points such as:

• Consistent employment history
• Strong, credible references
• Verified credentials
• No major policy or behavior concerns
  
  

A background check is not about assuming the worst. It’s about confirming the truth so the business can hire safely.

Because the truth is, most businesses are not trying to be overly cautious. They just don’t want to be the company that hired the “perfect candidate” who turned out to be perfect at creating chaos.

Call Lewis Investigations, Inc. for Professional Employee Background Investigation in Independence, OH

Trusted Pre-Employment Background Checks for Businesses That Want to Hire With Confidence

If your business needs reliable pre-employment background checks and a professional employee background investigation, our team at Lewis Investigations, Inc. is here to help. We serve Independence, OH and the surrounding areas, providing discreet investigative support that helps companies reduce hiring risks and protect workplace culture.

In addition to corporate investigations, we also offer insurance investigations, personal investigations, and polygraph services for businesses that need deeper verification or support during sensitive cases. Call 216-440-4779today to speak with our team and get dependable investigative services that help you make smarter hiring decisions.

FAQs